In the Matter of Robert Wargocki, Carteret, Police Department, CSC Docket No. 2024-632, 2024-633
NJ Civil Service Commission decision of September 23, 2026, CSC Docket No. 2024-632: discipline, penalty reversed. Robert Wargocki, a Police Captain, with the Borough of Carteret, Police Department, appeals his two 15 working day suspensions, on charges of incompetency, inefficiency, or failure to p
Robert Wargocki, a Police Captain, with the Borough of Carteret, Police Department, appeals his two 15 working day suspensions, on charges of incompetency, inefficiency, or failure to perform duties; insubordination; conduct unbecoming a public employee; and other sufficient causes.
Case facts
Official decision (PDF)- Matter
- Discipline
- Outcome
- Penalty reversed
- Decided
- September 23, 2026, item A-3
More case detailsAdditional facts from the record
- ALJ's recommendation
- Reverse the two 15 working day suspensions.
- What the Commission did with it
- Adopted the ALJ's recommendation
- Penalty appealed
- 15 working day suspension
- Title
- POLICE CAPTAIN
- Employer
- Carteret Borough
- Police department
- Carteret Police Department on Police Transparency NJ
- Chair at the time
- Mary Cruz, Acting Chairperson
Video: What the Civil Service Commission decides (2:20, captions and transcript).
Action recorded in the minutes
The Civil Service Commission affirmed the recommendation of the Administrative Law Judge.
Key passage
Quoted from the decision.
The Commission further orders that the appellant be granted 30 working days of back pay, benefits, and seniority.
Having considered the record and the ALJ’s initial decision, including a thorough review of the exceptions and reply, and having made an independent evaluation of the record, the Civil Service Commission (Commission), at its meeting of September 23, 2026, accepted and adopted the Findings of Fact and Conclusions as contained in the attached ALJ’s initial decision and her recommendation to reverse the two 15 working day suspensions.
Issues
Our classification of the matter, from the minutes and the rules the decision cites.
The decision
The attached ALJ initial decision is not reproduced here. Open the official PDF for the attachment.
Commission decision text; labels, links and ¶ are ours.
BackgroundThe appeals of Robert Wargocki, Police Captain, Carteret, Police Department, of two 15 working day suspensions, on charges, were heard by Administrative Law Judge Sarah G. Crowley, who rendered her initial decision on August 17, 2026. Exceptions were filed on behalf of the appointing authority and a reply was filed on behalf of the appellant. ¶
AnalysisHaving considered the record and the ALJ’s initial decision, including a thorough review of the exceptions and reply, and having made an independent evaluation of the record, the Civil Service Commission (Commission), at its meeting of September 23, 2026, accepted and adopted the Findings of Fact and Conclusions as contained in the attached ALJ’s initial decision and her recommendation to reverse the two 15 working day suspensions. ¶
Administrative Law JudgeIn this matter, the ALJ’s findings and conclusions are predominantly based on her assessment of the credibility of the witness testimony in the record. In this regard, the appointing authority’s exceptions can, in essence, be boiled down to its disagreement with those determinations. As indicated above, the Commission has thoroughly reviewed the exceptions filed by the appointing authority and finds them unpersuasive. In this matter, the ALJ made explicit credibility determinations. Specifically, the ALJ stated: ¶
Having had an opportunity to carefully observe the demeanor of the witnesses, it is my view that the testimony of Officer Kelly and former Chief McFadden was not credible, and their testimony was inconsistent with the facts and the documentation in this matter. I found the deputy chief’s testimony regarding the appellant’s request for another officer’s time off, not credible. It is clear from the significant number of emails from the appellant to the deputy chief that he was very careful to follow all orders and to clarify what was requested of him. Deputy Kelly testified that he had the form in his hand which the appellant had brought to him, and he usually wrote, approved or denied. The respondent provided no explanation for why they did not have this form and could not explain what happened to it. With respect to the testimony of the deputy and chief regarding the street light outage reports, the documents speak for themselves about a change in long standing policy, or lack thereof. There was no documentation other than two tersely worded emails, no follow-up for months and no investigation into why the lieutenants, who are the one[s] who failed to complete the task, were not disciplined. There was also no memorialization of this policy. By their own admission, the appellant had directed his staff to complete this task and very careful clarification of what was being asked of him. ¶
I found the testimony of Captain Wargocki sincere and credible and consistent with his emails and his efforts to follow all orders and requests of him. With respect to the streetlight outage reports, the new policy was not clear and never memorialized. Moreover, neither the chief nor the deputy chief followed up on the policy for three months. Finally, the appellant had ordered his staff to complete the task, and they did not complete it consistently with this new policy which had never been memorialized. There was no inquiry as to why they had not followed the captain’s orders and no discipline imposed on those that failed to follow order[s]. I found Captain Wargocki’s testimony that the deputy chief had approved the request for time off credible and the deputy chief’s testimony that he denied it not credible. ¶
AnalysisThe Commission acknowledges that the ALJ, who has the benefit of hearing and seeing the witnesses, is generally in a better position to determine the credibility and veracity of the witnesses. See Matter of J.W.D., 149 N.J. 108 (1997). “[T]rial courts’ credibility findings . . . are often influenced by matters such as observations of the character and demeanor of the witnesses and common human experience that are not transmitted by the record.” See also, In re Taylor, 158 N.J. 644 (1999) (quoting State v. Locurto, 157 N.J. 463, 474 (1999)). Additionally, such credibility findings need not be explicitly enunciated if the record as a whole makes the findings clear. Id. at 659 (citing Locurto, supra). The Commission appropriately gives due deference to such determinations. However, in its de novo review of the record, the Commission has the authority to reverse or modify an ALJ’s decision if it is not supported by sufficient credible evidence or was otherwise arbitrary. See N.J.S.A. 52:14B-10(c); Cavalieri u. Public Employees Retirement System, 368 N.J. Super. 527 (App. Div. 2004). In this matter, the exceptions filed are not persuasive in demonstrating that the ALJ’s credibility determinations, or her findings and conclusions based on those determinations, were arbitrary, capricious or unreasonable. As such, the Commission has no reason to question those determinations, or the findings and conclusions made therefrom. ¶
Since the suspensions have been reversed, the appellant is entitled to 30 working days of back pay, benefits, and seniority pursuant to N.J.A.C. 4A:2-2.10. Moreover, the appellant is entitled to reasonable counsel fees pursuant to N.J.A.C. 4A:2-2.12. ¶
This decision resolves the merits of the dispute between the parties concerning the disciplinary charges and the penalty imposed by the appointing authority. However, per the Appellate Division’s decision, Dolores Phillips v. Department of Corrections, Docket No. A-5581-01T2F (App. Div. Feb. 26, 2003), the Commission’s decision will not become final until any outstanding issues concerning counsel fees are finally resolved. ¶
ORDER
The Civil Service Commission finds that the action of the appointing authority in suspending the appellant was not justified and grants the appeals of Robert Wargocki. The Commission further orders that the appellant be granted 30 working days of back pay, benefits, and seniority. The amount of back pay awarded is to be reduced as provided for in N.J.A.C. 4A:2-2.10(d)3. The Commission also orders reasonable counsel fees pursuant to N.J.A.C. 4A:2-2.12(a). Proof of income earned, and an affidavit in support of reasonable counsel fees shall be submitted by or on behalf of the appellant to the appointing authority within 30 days of issuance of this decision. ¶
Pursuant to N.J.A.C. 4A:2-2.12(b), the parties shall make a good faith effort to resolve any dispute as to the amount of counsel fees. ¶
The parties must inform the Commission, in writing, if there is any dispute as to counsel fees within 60 days of issuance of this decision. In the absence of such notice, the Commission will assume that all outstanding issues have been amicably resolved by the parties and this decision shall become a final administrative determination pursuant to R. 2:2-3(a)(2). After such time, any further review of this matter shall be pursued in the Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division. ¶
Rules cited in this decision
Statutes behind these rules
Sections of N.J.S.A. Title 11A this decision cites, and those the cited rules were adopted under.
- 11A:1-1 through N.J.A.C. 4A:2-2.10
- 11A:2-22 through N.J.A.C. 4A:2-2.12
- 11A:11-5 through N.J.A.C. 4A:2-2.12
Decisions this one cites
About this page
Not an official copy. The decision of record is CSC's PDF. The text above was extracted from it and may differ in layout or in a character. This reader covers the Commission decision text, including ALJ passages quoted within it, rather than every document bundled with the source PDF.
Names appear as the Commission published them in its public minutes and decisions, initials where it used initials. The decision search finds a name only as the Commission printed it, never from initials, and there is no page or list for a person.
The labels are ours. The kind of matter and the outcome are our reading of the minutes; the ACTION text the Commission recorded is quoted verbatim above. A decision applies the rules to its own facts and is not a prediction for any other matter, and nothing here is legal advice.
To report an error on this page, use the contact form.